Unconventional Scales: Exploring Musical Worlds Beyond the Tonal System

Published On: September 25, 2023Categories: Inside the Music5.8 min read

Music stretches far beyond the familiar borders and tones of the West. While major and minor tonal scales have painted the world of countless symphonies, pop hits, and folk songs, an expansive space of unconventional scales promises fresh adventures and novel musical narratives if we are looking to expand our soundscape. This musical richness has its roots deep within our history. Long before Western musical theories were crystallized into a tonal system, cultures around the globe were crafting their unique musical systems and scales.

In music, a scale is a collection of pitches arranged in ascending or descending order by frequency or pitch. The scale serves as a foundational melodic and harmonic blueprint for composing and improvising in a particular key. The specific collection of pitch classes for a scale defines the key’s tonality or mode.

 

The most common scales in Western music are the major and minor scales, but there are numerous other scales, each with its own unique set of intervals and sonic characteristics.

For instance, Ancient Greece had musical “modes” like the Dorian, with a bluesy feel, and the Lydian, which sounds dreamy due to its raised fourth note. The Middle East’s Maqam system, central to Arabic and Persian traditions, comprises melodic structures with specific intonations designed to evoke particular emotions. Asian music features scales such as China’s tranquil pentatonic, built on five notes, and Indonesia’s gamelan scales, Slendro and Pelog, which have unique tonal palettes distinct from Western scales. Each scale is deeply rooted in its cultural and historical context.

The exploration of these unconventional scales not only enriches our sonic palette but also deepens our appreciation for the diverse cultures from which they originate. Venturing beyond major and minor scale reveals a diverse and vibrant world of unconventional sets of sounds, each encapsulating its region’s spirit and stories.

Here some scales you might not know:

Pelog (Balinese) The heart of Bali’s enchanting gamelan music beats to the rhythm of the Pelog scale. With seven “potential” pitches, though typically using only five in most compositions, its distinct intervals give it a sonic character that’s both intriguing and exotic. This scale carries the ambiance of Balinese ceremonies, dances, and rituals, where the music transcends entertainment and intertwines with spirituality.

 

Maqam (Middle Eastern) Dominating the Arabic music for centuries, the Maqam is more than just a scale; it’s a musical narrative. Each Maqam (there are 72!) is characterized by specific melodic phrases and intonations, seeks to evoke distinct emotions. The Maqam Hijaz, for example, is often associated with longing, while the Maqam Rast emanates a sense of stability and neutrality. These scales not only define melodies but are deeply embedded in the region’s history and culture.

Indian Raga System India’s musical heritage is vast and profound, with the Raga system at its core. A raga is a structured melodic framework, enriched with ascending (Aroha) and descending (Avaroha) patterns, unique characteristic phrases (Pakad), and specific note embellishments. Moreover, many ragas are associated with specific moods, times of the day, or even seasons.

Whole Tone and Octatonic Scales (Western Art Music) Emerging from Western art music’s quest to break tonal boundaries, the whole-tone scale, dividing the octave into six equal parts, creates an atmosphere of dreaminess. The octatonic or diminished scale, alternating between whole and half steps, offers a rich ground for avant-garde compositions. Pioneers like Debussy and Stravinsky frequently employed these scales, crafting timeless pieces that challenged and expanded traditional tonal conventions.

Additional Unique Scales

  • Hirajoshi and Kumoi (Japanese): Central to Japan’s traditional Koto music, these scales evoke a sense of serenity. The Hirajoshi, in particular, is characterized by its pentatonic structure, capturing the essence of Japanese aesthetic and philosophical concepts.
  • African Pentatonic Scales: The African continent, with its vast cultures and traditions, often resonates to the pentatonic scales. These five-note scales, simple yet profound, serve as the foundation for a plethora of rhythms, songs, and dances across different African tribes and regions.
  • Mongolian Throat Singing Scales: This unique scale emerges from overtone singing, a vocal technique where a singer produces two distinct tones simultaneously. The melodies crafted using these harmonics result in ethereal and captivating soundscapes, mirroring the vastness of Mongolian landscapes.
  • Phrygian Dominant Scale: Often associated with flamenco music, this scale is a variation of the minor scale with a flattened second and a raised third. It has an exotic, Middle Eastern flavor, making it popular in various genres seeking that particular tonal color.

 

 

Implications for Musicians and Composers

Navigating the intricate pathways of unconventional scales offers more than just an expansion of the musical vocabulary—it represents an evolution of artistic expression. These scales breathe fresh life into compositions, introducing nuances that can elevate a piece from the familiar to the extraordinary. For composers, this exploration becomes a dual-edged sword; on one edge is the prospect of innovation and, on the other, the responsibility to honor the cultural roots of these scales.

The journey into the depths of global scales, while enlightening, isn’t lacking of pitfalls. There’s a thin line between appreciation and appropriation. Using a non-Western scale without understanding its roots, its cultural significance, or its traditional nuances can lead to superficial representations. It’s akin to knowing the words of a language but being oblivious to their true meaning. Each scale carries with it a legacy, a set of unspoken rules, and emotions. A cursory or misinformed usage can lead to compositions that, while technically accurate, might lack authenticity. Moreover, it might perpetuate stereotypes or distort the cultural narrative from which the scale originates. This underscores the importance of immersive learning, where understanding a scale is as much about its notes as it is about its history, ethos, and emotional resonance.

Embracing unconventional scales is not just an academic or artistic pursuit. It challenges us to listen, not just with our ears, but with our hearts. It invites us to step out of our musical comfort zones, to venture into uncharted territories, and to find unity in diversity. As we explore, compose, and listen, we don’t just celebrate notes; we celebrate narratives, histories, and the indomitable human spirit.

References

 

Nettl, B. (2005). The Study of Ethnomusicology: Thirty-One Issues and Concepts. University of Illinois Press.

Racy, A. J. (2003). Making Music in the Arab World: The Culture and Artistry of Tarab. Cambridge University Press.

Tenzer, M. (2000). Gamelan Gong Kebyar: The Art of Twentieth-Century Balinese Music. Chicago University Press

Powers, H. S., & Wiering, F. (2001). The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians. Macmillan.

Myers, H. (Ed.). (1992). Ethnomusicology: An Introduction. W. W. Norton & Company.

Slobin, M. (2005). Folk Music: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press.

Touma, H. H. (1996). The Music of the Arabs. Amadeus Press.

 

Special Note: This article is the result of a unique collaboration between Musica IQ’s editorial team and advanced AI technology, blending human expertise with data-driven insights to provide up-to-date information.


Copyright ©2023, Musica IQ. All rights reserved.

editor's pick

news via inbox

Subscribe for exclusive monthly music insights, artist features, and more. Don't miss a beat – join now!